Christmas Cookie Box

A Holiday Tradition Twenty Years in the Making

For more than twenty years, my mom has been creating Christmas Cookie Boxes that have become something of a legend in our family. Everyone who receives one treats it like a little treasure box, filled with the most sacred, sought after treats she dreams up each December. They’re talked about, anticipated, and adored. They feel like opening a little piece of holiday magic.

This year, she is widening her sacred circle to include our Baker’s Burrow customers. And I’m adding a few special touches of my own with a handmade gingerbread syrup and a signature Christmas tea blend.

✨ Each box will be lovingly packed in Christmas themed packaging with festive wrapping, plus a “to/from” card featuring Hazel the bunny all dressed up for the holidays.

✨ You can order a box as a gift with a personalized note, or order one for your own home as the coziest December treat. Every box is completely customizable. Mix and match as many cookie packs as you’d like!

✨ Please order at least 5 days before you need your box to allow time for baking and assembly. Local customers can pick up their boxes at Weldon Coffee.

Christmas Cookie Box Menu

4 cookies per pack · $8

Chocolate Cherry Cookies
A family favorite for as long as I can remember. Soft, dark chocolate, fudgy brownie-based thumbprint cookies filled with cherry-infused ganache and topped with a bright maraschino cherry. Rich, nostalgic, and the perfect balance of deep cocoa and sweet cherry.

Almond Shortbread
A true Baker’s Burrow favorite. Buttery, soft almond-infused shortbread sticks drizzled with an almond-flavored powdered sugar glaze and finished with sliced almonds. Delicate, fragrant, and melt-in-your-mouth with a cozy holiday sweetness.

Pecan Snowballs
Simple and classic. Light, buttery cookies dotted with finely chopped pecans and rolled generously in powdered sugar. Soft, crumbly, and melt-in-your-mouth Christmas comfort.

Gingerbread Cookies
Triple ginger for true gingerbread lovers. Made with fresh ginger, crystallized ginger, and powdered ginger, plus warm spices and a hint of pepper for depth. Soft, spiced, cozy, and wonderfully fragrant.

Coconut Squares
Sweet, chewy coconut walnut bars layered over a buttery shortbread crust and finished with a drizzle of dark chocolate. Toasty, rich, and deeply satisfying with a perfect balance of crunch and chew.

Fig & Walnut Rugelach
One of our all-time favorites. Cream cheese pastry rolled with fig, walnut, cinnamon, and a tiny hint of orange zest to brighten each bite. Tender, flaky, spiced, and full of old-world holiday charm.

Peppermint Mocha Cookies
Peppermint-infused fudgy mocha cookies with a white chocolate drizzle and festive sprinkles. Soft, rich, and reminiscent of your favorite holiday coffee shop drink in cookie form.

Lemon Drops
If you’re a fan of our famous lemon brownies, you will adore these. Dense, bright, buttery lemon shortbread bites coated in powdered sugar and drizzled with zesty lemon glaze, then topped with sparkling sugar. Beautiful enough to be the centerpiece of a Christmas dessert tray.

Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our classic Baker’s Burrow fan favorite. Soft, chewy, and made with deeply toasted browned butter for a warm, toffee-like flavor. Perfect for holiday gatherings or gifting.

Snickerdoodle Cookies
Our classic, well-loved snickerdoodles. Soft, cinnamon-sugar coated, nostalgic, and the coziest addition to any Christmas cookie assortment.

Shortbread Bites
Our classic buttery shortbread all dressed up for Christmas with a sweet vanilla glaze and festive holiday sprinkles. Simple, charming, and timeless.

Cashew Brittle · $6
A Baker’s Burrow staple. Soft-crunch, buttery brittle loaded with roasted cashews, perfectly balanced with sweetness and a touch of salt. A dangerously snackable treat.

Cinnamon Almonds · $6
Warm, addictive, cinnamon-sugar roasted almonds that fill the kitchen with the smell of Christmas. Crunchy, cozy, and a customer favorite.

Gingerbread Syrup (4 oz jar) · $5
Molasses-forward and beautifully spiced with ginger, cinnamon, and clove. Perfect for making gingerbread lattes at home or drizzling over pancakes, waffles, or oatmeal for an instant holiday upgrade.

Christmas Tea (4 tea bags) · $4
A sweet and spiced ruby-red tea blend of rooibos, cinnamon, clove, allspice, cardamom, and hibiscus. Perfect for Christmas gift wrapping by the fire, a calm pause during holiday bustle, or tucked into a stocking as a cozy little gift.